EAST LANSING — Whether or not to reconfigure Hagadorn Road between
Grand River Avenue and Haslett Road will go to a vote of the East
Lansing City Council on Tuesday, Oct. 2.
Council members spent close to 90 minutes asking questions and taking
public comment at their Sept. 25 work session.
None of the five council members gave any open indication of how they
would vote on the issue, a hotly debated topic since the fall of 2005.
The recommendation went to the city council after a 4-3 vote of the
Transportation Commission on Sept. 17 fell one short of overturning the
original vote to recommend the change (taken in October 2006).
Do nothing.
In its final report, DLZ Michigan estimated the cost for option A at
$238,000 and the cost for option B at $156,000. If the council approves
the conversion, work could not begin until July 1, 2008, at the
earliest, as outgoing Mayor Sam Singh said there are no funds in the
current budget for the work.
According to the report, the estimate for option A would not include
the tab for purchasing a three-foot easement "from a significant number
of property owners," director of public works Todd Sneathen said.
With the exception of Tuesday's meeting, which was almost evenly
divided between those in favor and those against, public comment has
been strongly opposed to the proposal.
Woodside Drive resident Larry Cross, a member of the stakeholders'
committee, is opposed to changing the road configuration. He pointed out
the status of Hagadorn as a heavily-traveled north-south road.
"If there are 15,000 or 16,000 cars traveling on that road in a day,
I would be willing to bet that there's not one percent (of bicyclists)
traveling up and down there," Cross said.
"I'm wondering why we're putting so much onto a very small minority.
Let's put them on a safer street where we can handle it better."
Others, like Foxcroft Road resident Mathew Reeves, said a
lane-reduction would inspire a change in attitudes. Reeves is an
Michigan State University professor who, by his own count, bikes to his
office 10 to 11 months of the year.
"Whether this great state was founded on the automobile or not, we
need to start thinking about alternative models," Reeves told council
members.
With potential effects of a change on the traffic to and from Marble
Elementary School and McDonald Middle School at stake, council member
Diane Goddeeris asked East Lansing Public Schools Board member Chris
Ambrose whether the school board has taken an official position on the
proposal.
Ambrose answered that, to his knowledge, Marble Principal Jo Preston
— like himself, a member of the stakeholder committee — is opposed to
the change.
However, Ambrose said the school board does not have an official
position.
Council members discussed one alternative: The installation of a
traffic light at Hagadorn and Albert. Such a light, DLZ Michigan
representative Wes Butch said, would foster larger traffic buildups on
Hagadorn but would improve access to the road for residential traffic
exiting nearby side streets.
The cost of installating a light would run between $60,000 and
$80,000, including installation and maintenance.
City manager Ted Staton said that work is commonly contracted out to
the Board of Water and Light in Lansing.
Tuesday's meeting will start at 7:30 p.m. in the council chambers,
and will be televised.
Contact Dawn Parker at
dlparker@gannett.com or (800) 543-9913, ext. 506.